“I feel safe with the camera. That thing up there (pointing to the camera) sees everything and I get help when I need it”.
- Patient aged 100+Physical checks during the night can be very disturbing for patients. If they wake up they will often get out of bed which, in turn, could lead to a fall and possible injuries.
Users with cognitive impairment or some form of dementia could become upset if they wake up during a physical visit.
Physical visits also require a lot more staff as they are very time consuming. It is difficult to recruit staff and in the future we will have an older population with increased needs. It will be difficult to match such needs with the same workforce we have today. Thus, new work models are needed.
A camera and mobile router is installed in the user’s home and the camera is directed at the bed. Sometimes, an antenna amplifier is needed. If the camera cannot be reached an alarm is triggered and a technician will handle the issue.
It is rare for a camera to malfunction. When this occurs the most common reason is that the camera has been unplugged due to cleaning. Digital checks take place at specific times during the night, as agreed with the user, by an assistant nurse at a central unit in the municipality. In Kramfors, a central unit handles all digital checks. The unit makes 30 checks per night, which takes a total of around 15 minutes. This constitutes around 26% of all night checks in Kramfors. In comparison, driving to remote parts of the municipality can take 50 minutes, one way. In other municipalities, for example, Skellefteå, the same night patrol that makes physical visits is also responsible for the digital checks and makes 92 digital checks each night. About 46% of all Swedish municipalities offer some form of digital night monitoring.
Almost all physical checks have to be physical as other tasks must be performed, e.g. help visiting the bathroom, changing incontinence aids, etc.
Digital night monitoring is free of charge for the user. Physical visits are charged according to a standard hourly rate.
The equipment is leased from the service provider and costs SEK 450 per month, per user. In Kramfors this is paid for by the municipality.
It is much more efficient for the municipality to use digital monitoring than make physical visits as there is no need to use transport. A digital check take significantly less time.
The implementation process is not difficult but a decision must be made regarding who does what. Also, a clear process assessment must be performed.
Training for staff who will be conducting the monitoring takes one hour and training for technicians takes three hours. Naturally, staff training is not very time consuming. More time will need to be spent on information and marketing. It is very important to notify potential users and the public early in the process and it will be a challenge to do this in the most optimal way, e.g. marketing via different channels, attending meetings with elderly people, being proactive with the media. Dealing with negative articles and comments can be difficult so it is best to engage the media early in the process and provide examples of positive cases. You could perhaps provide information or write articles yourself. Information meetings must be also held with staff who work within elderly care so that they, in turn, can be good ambassadors.
It was not necessary to make any political decisions in Kramfors, although the local politicians were informed early in the process.
-
Follow-ups are regulated by law and take place 1–2 times per year. Every service that a user receives is evaluated.
-
It is important to be proactive when it comes to communication about digital night monitoring in order to make people understand that it is not about surveillance.
This issue concerns both the general population and potential users, politicians and the media. It is important to attend meetings and answer all questions posed by worried users and their relatives.
In Kramfors, a municipality comprising around 18,000 inhabitants, the use of digital night monitoring replaces 5.8 hours in a car every night and 2,118 hours in a car per year. This is time that can be used more effectively on patients that need it.
There are also obvious positive effects for the environment. 173 kilometres of car travel can be replaced by digital checks every night and 63,080 kilometres per year.
Patients can enjoy an undisturbed night’s sleep and still feel safe using this solution, knowing that if something happens it will be noticed by staff via the camera, and that the patient’s needs will be addressed via a physical visit. Assistant nurses in home care can dedicate their time to patients that really need a physical visit, i.e. meet the patient’s needs in situ, using the appropriate measures.
Effects for the patient
Effects for the care giver
Other effects
Do you want to know more about the solution?
An effort should be made to identify enthusiasts in the organization who can help with engagement, marketing and competence. It is also important to get full support from social service workers for the elderly, since they play a key role in deciding what service a specific user is entitled to receive. They must have fully trust in digital night monitoring, otherwise it will be hard to expand its use.
And again, being proactive when it comes to communication is a major issue.
Do you want to know more about the solution?
Watch a short movie about the solution ▶︎
Information about digital night monitoring on Kramfors municipality website »
Information about digital night monitoring on Skellefteå municipality website »
The solution is described in two reports from the National Board of Health and Welfare:
E-health and welfare technology in municipalities 2018 (PDF)
A study of the use of security cameras and GPS alarms in 12 municipalities (PDF)
All information is in swedish.
Digital night monitoring can be used in all municipalities and is appropriate for all users for whom a physical visit is not required. Naturally, rural communities are particularly suitable as significant distances can be involved, although the solution can also be used in more urban areas.
David Wiklund, Verksamhetsutvecklare teknik, Kvalitetsledning & hälsa, Välfärdsförvaltningen, Kramfors kommun
Phone: +46 612-803 60, david.wiklund@kramfors.se
Anna-Maria Andersson, Verksamhetsutvecklare, Socialkontoret, Skellefteå kommun
Phone: +46 70-623 24 14, anna-maria.andersson@skelleftea.se
Kramfors municipality uses Tunstall and Skellefteå municipality uses Great Security.
Tunstall
Great Security